Appointed watchdog details first report into DCFS since toddler’s fentanyl overdose death: ‘Instances of miscommunication’

BATON ROUGE — Communication problems and confusing procedures hamper the state’s efforts to take better care of children who need help, the state child ombudsman said Monday. An ombudsman is a basically a non-partisan official, or a watchdog, who investigates complaints regarding government agencies responsible for children, such as foster care, child protective services, and juvenile justice, according to the National Conference of State Legislators.

Kathleen Richey, a longtime juvenile court judge in East Baton Rouge Parish, was appointed to the ombudsman position when it was created in 2023 within the legislative auditor’s office.

At a hearing on Monday, lawmakers on the Senate Select Committee on Women and Children got the inaugural report from Richey.

“I think that the underlying purpose that the legislature has is just what you’re saying: identify where we have failed this child, so that we do not fail any other children. But I’m not sure that we have set up a process that’s capable of doing that,” Richey said.

Richey’s role was created in part to try to stop child deaths like that of Mitchell Robinson III. Robinson, 2, died in 2022 from ingesting fentanyl.

It was the third time he was hospitalized with that kind of drug exposure. Reports from hospital personnel did not prompt the the Department of Children and Family Services to remove the child from his parents’ care after the first two times he had to be hospitalized.

MORE: Doctor notified DCFS twice prior to 2-yr-old’s death of possible fentanyl overdoses

The investigation of what went wrong in that case led to the departure of a DCFS secretary and eventually to the establishment of the ombudsman office. The ombudsman takes complaints from people involved in DCFS cases, members of the public, medical staff and even DCFS employees.

MORE: “Multiple failures” by DCFS blamed on Baton Rouge toddler’s fentanyl death

Richey’s report touched on several problems with how DCFS and related agencies handle information about child placements with relatives, confidentiality and how information about child deaths is tracked and shared.

Richey told the committee that she had good relationships with DCFS regional administrators. When she received a complaint that needed an urgent response, she said, she would call the administrators directly. Last month, she was told to submit requests for information to an email account.

“We had been having really good communication lines with regional administrators. That changed this month, and now we are instructed to email so our communication is through an email box, and I don’t know who’s answering those emails. Many of them haven’t been answered,” Richey said.

DCFS Secretary Rebecca Harris told the committee that the email procedure was established because important information being discussed with regional administrators did not always reach top administrators at the agency.

“There were a lot of instances where there was miscommunication as to who was responsible for different information, related to either providing information back to the ombudsman or receiving information,” Harris told the committee.

The email account was overseen by the agency’s attorney and two top administrators, she said. She acknowledged that that information may not have been given to Richey and her staff.

Richey said difficulties between her office and the DCFS office were not the only ways communication needs to improve. Of 371 complaints made to the ombudsman’s office in 2025, 230 of them dealt with communication difficulties for people involved in DCFS cases. The complaints reported calls that were not returned, inadequate information or misinformation, the annual report said.

Tension and mistrust characterized some of the exchanges during the hearing, which was held in two parts, breaking so committee members could meet with the full Senate to conduct the day’s legislative business.

Sen. Paul McMath, R-Mandeville, read from an email DCFS sent to the committee chairs. In it, DCFS called part of Richey’s report “irresponsible” because of a criminal investigation underway in one of the cases mentioned.

“The content of the report appears to exceed the ombudsman’s lane,” he read from the email.

Later in the hearing, Sen. Beth Mizell, R-Franklinton, said she is worried that DCFS doesn’t seem open to others identifying and working to solve problems.

“The impression I get is that there is a wall of protection, that ‘I’m not going to let you see what can be fixed. I’m not going to acknowledge it’s broken’, frankly, so that we can never get to fix it. And everybody on here wants to fix it. I’m sick to death of looking at our numbers and seeing our ranking and knowing every number is a child whose life was taken away. But that doesn’t mean you’ve done anything wrong. I get the feeling that you think we doubt your sincerity, that we think that you’re having to prove that to us,” Mizell said. “And, I mean, maybe we should be sitting over a cup of coffee or something, and that’s part of my frustration. We’re not here to make life harder. We’re here to make things better for the kids.”

Sen. Katrina Jackson-Andrews, D-Monroe, told Harris that lawmakers don’t expect her to have the decades-long problems in DCFS already resolved.

“You’ve only been there six or seven months, and now you have a legislature willing to make changes. I would welcome that opportunity. After what we’ve seen, I would really welcome the opportunity for change, because something’s broken. It’s systematically broken,” she said.

Committee members, Richey and Harris identified problems with the system used to track child deaths in Louisiana.

The reports provided by DCFS to the ombudsman don’t include the child’s name, but do include the town where the child lived. It becomes confusing if the child is hospitalized in a different town or parish. When the child dies, the death information is associated with the location where the child died, making it hard to match initial reports with investigation outcomes.

Richey said she had been working with DCFS to develop a “memorandum of understanding” for procedures in child death cases.

“We have not been able to finalize it. It’s not been signed,” she said.

The ombudsman office is supposed to notify lawmakers of child deaths, but the law calls for notification only when abuse or neglect are found to have contributed to the death.

McMath said he was aware of a child in foster care in St. Tammany Parish who had died this year. He wondered why that death wasn’t included in the statistics passed along to the Legislature.

DCFS officials said that the St. Tammany death was related to a medical condition and was not the result or abuse of neglect. That doesn’t trigger the notification process.

Several senators were surprised to learn that they were not receiving information about every child death in DCFS custody.

“I feel really misled,” said Sen. Regina Barrow, D-Baton Rouge.

Jackson-Andrews summed up the frustration.

“Something has to move. Something has to change,” she said.

Richey brought the conversation back to Robinson, the toddler who died after repeatedly ingesting fentanyl. Before the ombudsman role was created, she said, she had assisted the inspector general’s office in examining the Robinson case.

“So I did listen to all of the calls for investigation and review policies and processes, and I don’t know that we’ve made enough progress be confident that we have won’t have that situation again,” she said.

The Senate Health and Welfare Committee sent that bill to the Senate Tuesday after some amendments.

Download the Unfiltered with Kiran app from the Apple App Store and Google Play to stay updated on the latest news across the Capital area. 

Support UWK and its mission to deliver The News You Deserve. Unfiltered. Become a monthly patron on Patreon today!

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Interested in advertising with us?

We’d love to have you on the team! Drop us a line and we’ll be happy to follow up. 

Categories

Let's Connect

Follow along on your favorite social media platform and get the latest updates directly in your feed!

Submit a Tip

Have a tip on a story? Send it directly to our team using the form below!
Search