
BATON ROUGE — In a meeting that went nearly 10 hours and lasted till 4:30 a.m. on Wednesday, there were all the ingredients for a true Louisiana political gumbo: laughter, tears, hostility, allegations of racism, references to Ku Klux Klan robes and threats to hold lawmakers accountable. What started around 7 p.m. and went through the night till Wednesday morning, the state Senate and Governmental Affairs Committee chose to move forward with a Republican-proposed congressional district map.
The sometimes tense, emotional marathon hearing followed a combative 8-hour hearing Friday during which more than 50 people testified about four bills with different maps.
On Tuesday evening after the full Senate completed its work for the day, the Senate and Governmental Affairs Committee got started.
It featured a slightly different lineup of members than the previous hearing because Sen. Gary Carter, D-New Orleans, took a voluntary leave of absence from the committee Tuesday. He had clashed with committee chair Sen. Caleb Kleinpeter, R- Port Allen, and bill author Sen. Jay Morris, R- West Monroe, so fiercely that Carter apologized Monday to the full Senate. Sen. Royce Duplessis, D-New Orleans, replaced Carter on the committee.
Dozens of people testified before the vote. One of them supported Senate Bill 121, Morris’ bill that was amended Tuesday with a slightly different map than had been presented Friday.
Ultimately, the committee, by a 4-3 vote, agreed to report SB 121 favorably to the full Senate.
Morris’ map has been described as one likely to yield a congressional delegation of five white Republicans and one Black Democrat.
Sen. Ed Price, D- Gonzales, presented the competing bill, Senate Bill 407, which would likely have held the status quo with four white Republicans and two Black Democrats. In spite of the testimony from dozens of supporters who stayed at the Capitol until the wee hours of the morning, the committee rejected that bill.
Two alternative maps in separate bills that Morris had also proposed did not get any further consideration Tuesday. They had been discussed Friday.

The high-stakes political battle comes as legislators work out their next move in the process of redistricting. On April 29, the U.S. Supreme Court ruled the state’s existing congressional maps to be an unconstitutional race-based gerrymander.
That led Gov. Jeff Landry to suspend the election for congressional candidates, even though tens of thousands of mail-in ballots had already been returned. It is not yet clear how those ballots will be handled and many voters have said they are confused because the congressional races will still appear on voting machines Saturday.
MORE:Â UWK Election Guide
MORE:Â Breaking down the constitutional amendments before you go vote
Committee members on Friday said they wanted Secretary of State Nancy Landry to appear before the committee to answer questions about what happens to ballots already cast and those that may still be cast in the suspended races. On Tuesday, they were told that ongoing litigation made it impossible for her to do that.
Candidates and voters filed a federal suit in an effort to reverse Landry’s suspension of the races.
“The past is watching. The past is laughing.”
The hearing Tuesday had all the elements of political theatre that Louisianians have learned to expect from their elected officials. It had laughter, tears, hostility, allegations of racism, references to Ku Klux Klan robes and threats to hold lawmakers accountable at the ballot box.
It had comparisons of the state’s political and cultural landscape as a delicious gumbo in need of all the right seasonings. It had a visit from former state Senate and Democratic Party leader Karen Carter Peterson. It even had Democratic Socialists.
By the witching hour on Wednesday, most of the people who spoke to the committee had begun to acknowledge that the vote was not likely to go their way.
Joycia Bell wept as she told the committee that she grew up learning from her parents about the civil rights struggles of the 1950s and 1960s. She said she thought that strife was over.
“This is like living in a time warp. I don’t know. It’s like ‘what year is this?’ History – the past, present and future is watching. The past is watching. The past is laughing because it’s identifying with everything that’s happening. The present is shaking its head. The future, we’ve been hearing from last week. Our youth – I feel for our youth. I’m sorry to every young person in this room,” Bell said, resisting sobs. “They should not have to see this. And I’m sorry to every older person that fought, for every one of our people who have served, that fought. I’m so sorry. This should not be happening. But it is.”
Former state Rep. Melissa Flournoy, now the chair of 10,000 Women Louisiana, called the proposal “Jim Crow 2.0.”
Peterson told committee members she went through three rounds of redistricting when she was in office.
“This is one of those moments where you need to be accounted for,” she said. “Your vote will speak for you.”
Morris, who drew sharp questions from some of the Democrats on the committee, said he modeled the map in his bill on a 2022 map that was well-vetted and would have likely stood up to a court challenge. His version was created without racial considerations but does maintain “existing district cores,” he said.
Duplessis quizzed Morris about the proportion of Republicans and Democrats in the state and asked if he believed hs map was a fair representation of Louisiana voters.
“Yeah,” Morris said. “Everybody gets to vote under this map.”
“Everybody gets to vote,” Duplessis responded. “But does everybody get to elect someone who is going to represent their interests?”
“Some people win and some people lose,” Morris countered. “But no one gets to demand that they get the candidate they want to win, but they get to vote.”
Sens. Blake Miguez, R-New Iberia; Mike Fesi, Miller, R-Houma; and Glen Womack, R-Harrisonburg, voted in favor of SB 121. Sens. Regina Barrow, D- Baton Rouge, Same Jenkins, D- Shreveport, and Duplessis voted against. The bill now moves to the Senate for consideration.
Emily Walsh, who like many of those at the hearing spoke first in favor of Price’s bill and later against Morris’ bill, ran out of patience.
“I hope you never know another moment of peace in your life,” she said.
Download the Unfiltered with Kiran app from the Apple App Store and Google Play to stay updated on the latest news across the Capital area.Â
Support UWK and its mission to deliver The News You Deserve. Unfiltered. Become a monthly patron on Patreon today!


















