Fired BRPD officers Troy Lawrence, Doug Chutz & Todd Thomas

Fired BRPD officers lose first round of appeal, second set for February

BATON ROUGE — The Municipal Fire & Police Civil Service Board has rejected an appeal motion from three fired Baton Rouge Police officers, clearing the way for a full hearing on their terminations scheduled for February 24.

During a special hearing on January 13, the MFPCSB voted 4-1 to deny a motion for summary disposition. Former Baton Rouge police officers Troy Lawrence, Doug Chutz, and Todd Thomas argued their terminations were based on a flawed investigation.

The Investigation

The three officers were fired on September 20, 2024, while a fourth officer, Martele Jackson, resigned in lieu of termination. The firings followed a Baton Rouge grand jury indictment of all four officers on a total of 17 charges in June.

The indictments followed the arrests of Lawrence, Chutz, and Thomas on multiple charges related to an alleged coverup of the 2020 beating of a man in police custody. The officers were accused of destroying police body camera evidence to conceal the incident.

In their defense, the officers claim that former Baton Rouge Police Chief Murphy Paul and Sergeant Gayton Montgomery violated several laws and policies during the investigation. Based on these alleged violations, attorneys for the officers argue that their terminations were unlawful.

Appealing Terminations to Board

According to filings with the board, the officers allege that BRPD violated their rights under the Police Officer Bill of Rights and its own policy manual. These allegations include the following:

  • Untimely Investigation: The officers claim the officers claim that the internal affairs investigation exceeded the amount of time allowed by law. Internal affairs and administrative investigations must be completed within 75 days from start to finish, but the attorneys allege it took 94 days. Additionally, BRPD policy mandates that an investigation must begin within 14 days of receiving a complaint.
  • Unrecorded Interview: The initial interview of Officer Martele Jackson was allegedly not recorded, a violation of law.
  • Misconduct by the Lead Investigator: The officers allege that the lead investigator lied during the process and should have been terminated for his actions.

The officers assert that none of these procedural safeguards were upheld. If these claims are proven to be violations of law, BRPD policy, and the Police Officer Bill of Rights, the terminations of the three officers could potentially be overturned.

A Police Officer’s Bill of Rights

The “Police Officer Bill of Rights” is a Louisiana law designed to ensure fair and consistent investigations of police officers. It does not grant officers special privileges but instead requires departments to follow specific procedures during investigations, preventing potential abuse of power by police chiefs. Louisiana’s fire departments are afforded similar protections under the law.

If the law is violated, any resulting disciplinary action, including termination, must be fully reversed. This is the basis for the officers’ appeal, as they are requesting that their terminations be overturned due to alleged violations of the Bill of Rights during the investigation process.

Details of the Allegations

Chief Paul Exceeded the 75-Day Investigation Limit

The officers’ attorneys allege that Paul violated department policy by taking 94 days to complete the internal affairs investigation, which began on August 30, 2023, and concluded on December 1, 2023. Under BRPD policy, such investigations must be completed within 75 days.

The officers claim Paul fabricated a false narrative to cover up this violation, doing so only after being alerted to his mistake in a previous court filing.

Additionally, Sergeant Gayton Montgomery is accused of misrepresenting himself to Officer Martele Jackson during the investigation. Montgomery allegedly claimed to be a member of the Internal Affairs Division, though he was not assigned to it.

In response to these allegations, Paul’s attorney, Jim Raines, defended Montgomery’s actions during the hearing, stating, “This investigation is being conducted for criminal AND internal affairs.” He argued that Montgomery’s choice of words, even if misinterpreted, does not constitute a violation of the Police Officer Bill of Rights.

Failure to Record Officer Jackson’s Interviews

The officers allege that Chief Paul conducted multiple interviews with Officer Jackson on August 30, 2023, but failed to record any of them, as required by law. According to cellphone records, there were five calls between Paul and Jackson on that day, none of which were documented or recorded.

The officers’ attorneys cited precedent from several court rulings, asserting that the failure to record such interviews mandates the reversal of disciplinary actions, including terminations.

Lead Investigator Misconduct

The officers presented evidence claiming Sergeant Gayton Montgomery, the lead investigator, lied and refused to answer key questions during his internal affairs interview. When questioned about his handling of the investigation, Montgomery allegedly provided false information and invoked the Fifth Amendment to avoid answering other inquiries.

Under BRPD policy, employees cannot remain silent during internal affairs investigations. While statements made during such interviews cannot be used in criminal cases, refusing to cooperate can lead to termination. Despite this, public records indicate that Montgomery was neither terminated nor disciplined for his actions.

The officers argue that these alleged violations, including lying and failing to comply with internal affairs procedures, warrant a complete reversal of their terminations.

Download the Unfiltered with Kiran app from the Apple App Store and Google Play to stay updated on the latest news across the Capital area. 

Help support UWK and their mission to continue providing you “The News You Deserve. Unfiltered.” Sign up to become a monthly patron via Patreon.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Interested in advertising with us?

We’d love to have you on the team! Drop us a line and we’ll be happy to follow up. 

Categories

Let's Connect

Follow along on your favorite social media platform and get the latest updates directly in your feed!

Submit a Tip

Have a tip on a story? Send it directly to our team using the form below!
Search